St. Simons Island is packed with charm and comfort, making it a favorite spot for anyone craving a relaxing coastal escape. The 5 Most Highly Rated St Simons Island Hotels really show off the best of what this Georgia gem has to offer, whether you want historic vibes or sleek modern suites.
I’ve spent a lot of time digging into reviews and ratings to find the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels for your next trip. Each one brings something unique to the table, from location to amenities, and I’ll break down what makes them stand out.
1. Village Inn and Pub – One of the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels
The Village Inn and Pub is easily one of the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels. This adults-only inn has 28 rooms with a cozy English-inspired feel.
It’s right downtown, so you can stroll to the lighthouse, pier, and village shops in about five minutes. I love how close you are to restaurants and nightlife—no need to drive anywhere.
Rooms have air conditioning, flat-screen TVs, and free WiFi. Beds get lots of compliments, and you’ll find coffee makers and bathrobes in every room.
Housekeeping keeps things tidy every day. Breakfast is complimentary and includes hot egg sandwiches, fruit, and pastries.
The on-site pub has a lively atmosphere, sometimes with live music—though it always winds down by 11 PM. Out back, the pool area is shaded by oak trees, and parking is free.
Since it’s adults-only, things stay pretty peaceful. If you’re ready to lock in your dates, check current rates and availability at the Village Inn and Pub for a romantic escape.
2. Sea Gate Inn – Among the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels
Sea Gate Inn is a top pick if you’re after luxury and want easy beach access. This spot at 1015 Beachview Drive has 24 condo-style suites that feel more like private apartments than hotel rooms.
Suites come with full kitchens and private balconies. The bathrooms have jetted tubs and walk-in showers—pretty nice after a day in the sun.
I like that you’re just steps from East Beach, and restaurants and shops are a short stroll away. There are two outdoor pools and a terrace for lounging.
Parking and WiFi are free. People rave about the cleanliness and spaciousness, and if you snag an ocean-view suite, you’re in for a treat.
Book Your Stay: Reach out to Sea Gate Inn directly or use your favorite booking site to grab a suite at one of the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels.
3. The Grey Owl Inn – Part of the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels
The Grey Owl Inn is one of those hidden gems among the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels. Nestled on an acre with ancient oaks and water gardens, it feels worlds away from the crowds.
There are just five suites, each with a private bath and modern touches. You get air conditioning, a fridge, microwave, and either a balcony or patio. Bathrooms have rainfall showers and fancy bath products.
The location is super convenient—just a few minutes’ drive to the lighthouse and pier, and you can walk to the beach or local restaurants. Breakfast is cooked-to-order and changes daily, so you’re not stuck with the same old thing.
Relax in the hot tub or wander the gardens. WiFi and parking are free, and the whole place has a peaceful, personal vibe.
Ready to book? Check rates and availability at The Grey Owl Inn for your St. Simons Island trip.
4. Home2 Suites by Hilton St. Simons Island – A Reliable Pick from the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels
Home2 Suites by Hilton is a solid bet for families or anyone needing extra space. This hotel sits right next to the regional airport, so you might even spot a few planes taking off while you sip your coffee.
Suites have full kitchens—dishwasher, fridge, microwave, the works. You get air conditioning, free WiFi, and plenty of room to spread out.
The 24-hour front desk is helpful, and the outdoor pool is great for an evening dip. There’s a fitness center if you want to keep up your routine.
It’s about 1.5 miles from East Beach, and you’re close to downtown shops and dining. Staff get high marks for friendliness, and breakfast is included.
If you want to stay at one of the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels, check current rates and availability early—rooms fill up fast during busy times.
5. Hotel Simone – Luxury Among the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels
Hotel Simone is an adults-only boutique spot that’s all about luxury. There are just 25 suites, each with elegant furniture and modern touches.
You’re one block from East Beach, so you can walk to the sand or to restaurants and bars in minutes. Suites come with a kitchenette—microwave, espresso maker, the essentials.
There’s a rooftop terrace for sunset views, plus an outdoor pool and a 24-hour gym. The on-site bar is a nice bonus for evening drinks.
Guests love the friendly staff and spotless rooms. Breakfast is complimentary, and the artwork throughout the hotel gives it a unique feel.
If you want to experience one of the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels, book your stay at Hotel Simone for a mix of luxury and convenience.
How to Choose From the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels
Trying to pick between the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels? I’d say start with location—do you want to be right on the beach, near the lighthouse, or in the heart of the village?
Location and Proximity to Attractions
Personally, I lean toward hotels close to the island’s main sights. Walking distance to the pier and lighthouse is a big plus.
Beachfront hotels let you roll out of bed and onto the sand. If shopping and entertainment matter, the Village area is ideal.
Golfers might want to stay at a resort with its own course. If history is your thing, look for hotels near the Bloody Marsh Battle Site.
Some hotels offer shuttles, which can be a lifesaver if you’re not up for driving. It’s worth checking if that’s available.
Amenities and Guest Services
Pools and hot tubs are standard at most luxury spots, but it varies. Book spa treatments early if you want them—slots go fast in high season.
Fitness centers range from basic to pretty impressive. If you need to work, business centers are handy for quick printing or emails.
Concierge services can help with tours or dinner reservations. Pet policies and parking fees differ a lot, so double-check before you book.
Dining Options Nearby
The Village area has the most restaurants, so hotels there give you tons of choices. Beachfront hotels often serve up seafood with a view.
Complimentary breakfast can save you time and money. If you like to cook, look for a hotel with kitchenettes or suites.
Local seafood spots like Georgia Sea Grill and The Rooftop at Ocean Lodge are worth a visit. Don’t miss out on the fresh catch.
Ready to find your perfect match among the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels? Compare rates and amenities, and book your Georgia coast getaway.
| Hotel | Rating | Luxury Level | Price per Night (2 Guests) | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Village Inn and Pub | 9.8/10 | ★★★ | $211 | |
| Sea Gate Inn | 9.4/10 | ★★★★ | $130 | No.18 of 4-Star Select Hotels in Georgia |
| The Grey Owl Inn | 9.4/10 | ★★★★ | $240 | |
| Home2 Suites by Hilton St. Simons Island | 9.2/10 | ★★★ | $169 | |
| Hotel Simone | 9.1/10 | ★★★ | $286 |
* All prices exclude taxes and are subject to daily changes. Please refer to the actual booking page for the most up-to-date rates.
Evaluation and Summary: 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels
If you’re hunting for the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels, you’re in the right place. I’ve dug through guest ratings, prices, and the overall vibe of each spot to help you figure out where to stay.
Let’s get right to it. The Village Inn and Pub tops the list with a stellar 9.8 out of 10 rating, and it’ll run you about $211 per night.
Rating Breakdown: 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels
- Village Inn and Pub: 9.8/10 – Guests rave about its charm and hospitality.
- Sea Gate Inn: 9.4/10 – Best value at $130 a night, honestly tough to beat for the price.
- The Grey Owl Inn: 9.4/10 – If you’re after a boutique feel, this one’s for you.
- Home2 Suites by Hilton: 9.2/10 – You know what you’re getting here: reliable chain comfort.
- Hotel Simone: 9.1/10 – Sleek, modern, and a bit more luxurious.
Sea Gate Inn brings serious bang for your buck. It’s not just affordable; it’s also recognized as the #18 four-star hotel in Georgia. That’s a pretty solid combo, especially considering it has the lowest nightly rate among the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels.
Prices swing from $130 up to $286 per night. The Grey Owl Inn and Hotel Simone sit at the higher end, but they make up for it with boutique style and extra amenities.
All of these hotels scored over 9.0 out of 10 from guests. That’s not something you see everywhere, and it says a lot about the consistency you can expect from the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels.
Thinking about booking? I’d suggest checking current rates on your favorite booking site. Prices jump around, especially during peak seasons, so you might catch a deal or two if you’re lucky.
Click the hotel links above to check availability and lock in your spot at one of the 5 Most Highly Rated St. Simons Island Hotels.
