New Buffalo, Michigan puts you right on the edge of Lake Michigan with plenty of hotel choices. This little resort town draws people in for waterfront escapes, family trips, and relaxing weekends—especially since it’s just over an hour from Chicago.
I’ve done the legwork to highlight the best new buffalo hotels for your next Lake Michigan stay. Whether you want a full-service spot with marina views or a comfy chain hotel with modern perks, you’ll find something here that works for your budget and style.
Most new buffalo hotels keep you within walking distance of beaches, local eats, and outdoor fun. It’s no wonder this area stays busy all year long.
1. New Buffalo Inn & Spa
New Buffalo Inn & Spa sits right in the center of town, about a 12-minute walk from New Buffalo Beach. This spot offers a quiet, cozy escape with both inn rooms and spa services.
There are only 9 unique rooms and suites here, so it feels intimate. Some rooms welcome pets, which is great if you’re traveling with furry friends.
Every room has its own vibe and plenty of comfort. The on-site spa offers massages, facials, and hydrotherapy, plus extras like mud baths and foot soaks.
Couples can book massages together, or relax in the infrared sauna and oversized hot tub. You’re just six blocks from Snug Harbor, so Lake Michigan is always close by.
Free WiFi and express check-in make things easy. There’s also free parking on site.
Check-in starts after 4:00 PM, and you’ll need to check out before 11:00 AM. The main guest must be at least 21 years old.
TripAdvisor ranks this inn #3 among New Buffalo’s bed and breakfasts, with guests giving it a solid 4 out of 5 stars.
Thinking about a visit? Book your room at New Buffalo Inn & Spa for a laid-back New Buffalo getaway.
2. Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, MI
The Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo sits just off I-94 at exit 1. It’s a breeze to get to, whether you’re coming from Chicago or Detroit.
Lake Michigan’s sandy shoreline is only 1.5 miles away. Four Winds Casino is also just a quick drive from the hotel.
You get 80 rooms here, all with free high-speed WiFi, flat-screen TVs, mini fridges, and microwaves. The beds have Serta pillowtops and plenty of pillows for a good night’s sleep.
There’s an indoor pool and a fitness center if you want to work out or just relax. Every morning, guests enjoy a free hot breakfast. The front desk is always open, 24/7.
This hotel ranks #5 out of 8 new buffalo hotels on TripAdvisor, scoring 4 out of 5 with travelers. Recent rates start at about $144 per night for two adults.
Check-in starts at 4:00 PM, and check-out is before 11:00 AM. You’ll need to be at least 21 to book a room, and pets aren’t allowed here.
Ready to lock in your stay? Head to the Holiday Inn Express & Suites site to check dates and rates.
3. Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo
The Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo is just off Interstate 94 at Exit 1. You can get here easily from pretty much anywhere.
It’s close to all the good stuff. Four Winds Casino is a 7-minute drive, and Lake Michigan beaches are about 15 minutes away.
You can also swing by Warren Dunes State Park or explore the Harbor Country Wine Trail. Lighthouse Place Premium Outlets are nearby if you’re in the mood for shopping.
All 105 rooms have flat-screen TVs and free WiFi. Suites come with mini-fridges and microwaves, plus pillow-top mattresses for extra comfort.
You’ll get a free hot breakfast every morning. There’s an indoor pool and a fitness center, and the business center is open 24 hours if you need it.
A free shuttle runs to Four Winds Casino for guests. The front desk never closes, so you can check in anytime.
Guests must be at least 21 to check in. Check-in starts at 3:00 PM, and check-out is before 11:00 AM.
Would you like to book a room? Click here for room availability.
Amenities and Experiences at New Buffalo Hotels
New buffalo hotels serve up some impressive amenities, from waterfront dining to relaxing spa treatments. Many properties have restaurants with lake views or full-service spas for unwinding after a day outside.
On-Site Dining Options
The Harbor Grand Hotel features rustic Italian food by a cozy fireside, right on the harbor. The setting is hard to beat if you love water views while you eat.
Four Winds Resort offers several dining spots inside the hotel and casino, ranging from casual to upscale. You’ll find something for every appetite without even leaving the property.
Marina Grand Resort takes advantage of its Lake Michigan location, offering waterfront dining with outdoor seating. Lots of new buffalo hotels, like Holiday Inn Express, include free breakfast every morning.
Wellness and Spa Services
Four Winds Resort has a full spa and wellness area. Many rooms come with whirlpool tubs, and the spa menu is extensive.
Most new buffalo hotels include fitness centers. Some keep it simple, while others go all out with modern equipment.
Indoor pools are everywhere—many properties keep theirs heated year-round. The Harbor Grand Hotel focuses on wellness and personal service, making it a good pick for travelers who want to relax.
Nearby Attractions
New buffalo hotels put you close to Lake Michigan’s beaches, downtown shops, and Four Winds Casino. Most places are within walking distance of the best spots in town.
Accessibility to Downtown Attractions
Harbor Grand Hotel is right on the water, and you can get to Warren Dunes State Park in about 15 minutes on foot.
Downtown is packed with wineries and local shops. Most new buffalo hotels are less than a mile from the action.
Four Winds Casino draws plenty of visitors, and many hotels run shuttles or are just a quick drive away.
Lake Michigan beaches stretch for miles, and some hotels like Harbor Grand offer direct access.
You can stroll through the lakeside villages, with restaurants, galleries, and boutique stores just steps from most hotels.
Location Benefits
New buffalo hotels put you steps from the best of town—historic railroad sites, the beach, and everything in between. With the compact downtown, you can wander to maritime museums or waterfront restaurants without ever needing your car.
New Buffalo Railroad Museum
The railroad museum is just a few blocks from downtown hotels on South Whittaker Street. It’s an easy 10-minute walk from most places.
- Hours: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM (seasonal schedule)
- Contact: (269) 820-1504
- Location: 530 S Whittaker Street
The museum highlights New Buffalo’s roots as a major railroad stop. I found the vintage train cars and local artifacts pretty fascinating.
Families especially love the model trains and interactive displays. Staff offer tours that show how the railroad helped New Buffalo grow into a resort town.
Stay at a nearby hotel and you can easily pop over to this local gem.
Harbor Country Adventures
This adventure company is based in downtown New Buffalo on South Whittaker Street. Most new buffalo hotels are within a five-minute walk.
- Hours: 10:00 AM – 6:00 PM daily
- Phone: (269) 231-5867
- Address: 35 S Whittaker Street
Harbor Country Adventures rents kayaks, leads bike tours, and offers guided nature walks. Their kayak trips go along the Galien River and the Lake Michigan coast—sunset paddles are a personal favorite for the views.
You can also rent bikes here and get advice on the best trails for your skill level. Guided tours often stop at local wineries and breweries, which is a nice perk.
Every rental includes life jackets, paddles, and safety gear. You can choose between single and tandem kayaks, so groups or couples are covered.
Book your hotel early if you want to snag a spot on these outdoor adventures during busy months.
Oselka’s Snug Harbor Marina: Near New Buffalo Hotels
The marina sits right on West Water Street, just steps from waterfront hotels and some of the best new buffalo hotels in town.
You can walk there in minutes from most New Buffalo accommodations. Honestly, it doesn’t get much more convenient if you’re staying at any of the new buffalo hotels nearby.
Marina Details:
- Hours: 9:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Phone: (269) 469-2600
- Location: 514 W Water Street
This full-service marina rents pontoon boats, fishing boats, and jet skis by the hour or for the day. The crew gives basic boating instructions, which is a relief if you’re new to it.
Charter fishing trips go after salmon, trout, and perch in Lake Michigan. Captains handle all the gear and bait, so you can just show up and fish.
You can choose half-day or full-day trips, depending on how much time you want on the water. The marina store sells fishing licenses, tackle, and all the snacks you forgot to pack.
If you bring your own boat, they offer launching services. Fuel and pump-out services are right there too, which makes longer stays at new buffalo hotels even easier to manage.
Choose a waterfront hotel or one of the new buffalo hotels close by, and you can watch boats come and go from your room. Not a bad way to end the day, right?
New Buffalo Beach—A Perk of New Buffalo Hotels
New Buffalo’s main beach stretches along Marquette Drive. It’s right there, just steps from many new buffalo hotels on the lakefront.
Most accommodations put you on the sand in under two minutes. That kind of access is tough to beat.
Beach Information:
- Hours: 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Contact: (269) 469-1522
- Address: 200 Marquette Drive
The sandy beach runs for over a mile along Lake Michigan’s edge. Lifeguards keep an eye on swimmers throughout the summer.
The water usually stays warm from June until September. People love that about New Buffalo Beach.
You’ll find restrooms, changing areas, and picnic tables right by the shore. Kids can climb and play on the playground between swims.
Volleyball nets are set up for anyone who wants a little friendly competition. There’s always something happening on the sand.
Parking fills up fast on weekends. Luckily, guests at new buffalo hotels can stroll right to the beach without worrying about it.
The boardwalk links the beach with downtown’s restaurants and shops. Evening walks here? Honestly, the sunsets over Lake Michigan are something you won’t forget.
Book a room at one of the new buffalo hotels on the beach to make the most of your Lake Michigan getaway.
Hotel Rating Price Comparison
| Hotel Name | Rating | Luxury Level | Price for 2 (1 night) | Booking Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New Buffalo Inn & Spa | 9.0 / 10 | ★★★ | USD 255 | Book Now |
| Holiday Inn Express & Suites New Buffalo, MI | 8.8 / 10 | ★★ | USD 299 | Book Now |
| Fairfield Inn & Suites New Buffalo | 8.2 / 10 | ★★ | USD 199 | Book Now |
Note: Prices exclude taxes and may vary daily. Actual prices are as shown on the booking page.
