Shipshewana, Indiana is a quirky crossroads of Amish tradition and modern comfort. If you’re seeking the best place to stay, you’ll want to check out the Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels—these are the spots that guests just keep raving about.
Let’s be honest, picking the right hotel can totally shape your Shipshewana adventure. That’s why I dug into guest reviews and satisfaction scores to find the Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels.
From full-service inns with conference rooms to budget-friendly, no-frills spots, these hotels offer a range of perks and prices. Each one has its own charm and keeps guests coming back. I’ll also drop some thoughts about what’s nearby, so you can soak up the best of Amish country without missing a beat.
Farmstead Inn and Conference Center: Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels
The Farmstead Inn and Conference Center sits right across from the famous Shipshewana Flea Market. If you love shopping or you’re traveling with family, this spot is a no-brainer for your Amish country stay.
The hotel has 152 rooms with flat-screen TVs, microwaves, and mini fridges. You get free WiFi and cable, which is always a plus.
I slept well on the beds and had plenty of space to stretch out. Each morning, you’ll wake up to a free hot breakfast—no complaints there.
There’s an indoor pool, hot tub, and a fitness center for when you need to unwind. Kids can burn off energy on the playground or basketball court.
The cozy lobby has fireplaces that make you want to linger. Staff here are genuinely friendly and eager to help, which makes a difference.
You can park for free, and you’re within walking distance of shops and restaurants. Menno-Hof Museum and Blue Gate Theater are just a short stroll away.
Ready to book your stay? Check rates and availability at Farmstead Inn and Conference Center today.
Blue Gate Garden Inn
Blue Gate Garden Inn is the newest of the Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels. It opened in 2007 and has 154 guest rooms that mix modern touches with a bit of country coziness.
You’ll find an indoor pool, hot tub, and a 24-hour gym—nice for staying active or just relaxing. There’s even an ice cream shop and arcade on-site, which families seem to love.
The rooms have all the basics: fridge, microwave, flat-screen TV, plus coffee makers and free bottled water. It’s those little extras that make travel easier.
The complimentary breakfast buffet stands out—guests rave about the made-to-order omelets and the variety of hot and cold options. It’s a solid way to start your day.
Blue Gate Garden Inn is just minutes from downtown’s shops and the flea market. The Blue Gate Theatre is next door, so catching a show is super convenient.
Ready to book your stay? Check current room rates and availability to grab a spot at this guest favorite.
Van Buren Hotel
Van Buren Hotel is another solid pick among Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels. It’s got 84 clean and comfortable rooms just outside the bustle of downtown.
The hotel sits in the shopping district, and you can reach the Blue Gate Theater and flea market in about 10 minutes by car. Each room has air conditioning, fridge, flat-screen TV, and free WiFi.
Microwaves, desks, and private bathrooms with toiletries are standard. It’s all pretty straightforward and easy.
A free buffet breakfast runs from 6:00 AM to 10:00 AM, with hot items like eggs, sausage, and waffles. Cold options are there too if you’re not into big breakfasts.
The indoor pool and fitness center give you a place to unwind after a long day. The lobby’s fireplace and comfy chairs create a nice spot to relax.
Parking’s free and plentiful, so you can come and go without stress. The 24-hour front desk means help is always available.
Book your stay at Van Buren Hotel and use it as your base for exploring Shipshewana’s attractions and shops.
Super 8 by Wyndham Shipshewana
Super 8 by Wyndham Shipshewana rounds out the Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels. It’s right in the heart of Amish country on Van Buren Street and gets a steady 4 out of 5 rating from guests.
There are 36 rooms, all clean and comfy, with cable TV and coffee makers. Free Wi-Fi is included, so you can stay connected.
I like that breakfast is grab-and-go, making mornings less of a hassle. You’ll find eggs, bacon, and waffles—simple but satisfying.
The hotel’s close to the Blue Gate Performing Arts Center, so you can walk to concerts and shows. It’s a popular pick for event-goers.
Parking is on-site, though it can get a bit crowded if you’re driving a big vehicle. The nearest airport is about 75 kilometers away, so plan ahead if you’re flying in.
Book your stay at Super 8 by Wyndham Shipshewana for a no-fuss, comfortable base in Indiana’s Amish country.
What’s Around the Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels: Culture, Transit & Taste
Shipshewana is packed with Amish culture, easy transit options, and food that’ll make you rethink your diet. Everything’s close, so you can walk almost anywhere.
Cultural Attractions on Foot
The Shipshewana Area Historical Museum is smack in the middle of town. You can walk there from almost any hotel in under 10 minutes.
This museum showcases Amish and Mennonite history with local artifacts and displays. It’s open Tuesday through Saturday, 10 AM to 4 PM.
Shipshewana Flea Market runs every Tuesday and Wednesday from May to September. It’s huge—over 700 vendors selling antiques, crafts, and Amish-made goods.
You’ll find everything from quilts and furniture to fresh produce. It’s an experience, even if you’re just window-shopping.
The Menno-Hof Visitor Center is close by and gives a hands-on look at Amish life. There’s even a film about daily life in the community.
Transport Access & How-to Tips
Most of the Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels are within a three-block radius of downtown. Walking to the main sights usually takes 5 to 15 minutes.
Street parking is free around the town center. Look for marked spots along Van Buren and Morton Streets.
Fort Wayne International Airport is the closest major hub, about 45 miles away. The drive usually takes under an hour.
US Highway 20 cuts right through Shipshewana, connecting you to the Interstate in about 15 minutes. It’s pretty straightforward if you’re driving in.
Local taxis aren’t common, so I’d suggest bringing your own car or arranging rides through your hotel if you don’t want to hoof it everywhere.
Nearby Bites
Das Dutchman Essenhaus serves classic Amish meals just a couple of miles from most Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels. Their buffet is known for fried chicken, mashed potatoes, and pies as good as grandma’s.
Blue Gate Restaurant offers family-style dining with big portions. Don’t skip the broasted chicken and homemade bread.
Shipshewana Coffee Company is open bright and early at 6 AM. They serve fresh coffee and simple breakfast bites for folks on the go.
JoJo’s Pretzels twists up fresh, soft pretzels with plenty of topping choices. You can even watch them make the dough in the window.
Keep in mind, most restaurants close by 8 PM. If you’re a night owl, plan your meals a bit earlier.
Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels: Evaluation and Summary
Looking for the Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels? Well, you’re in the right place. I’ve dug into the details, and here’s what I found.
The Farmstead Inn and Conference Center sits at the top with a guest rating of 9.4 out of 10. It’s priced at $162 per night, which honestly feels like a steal for what you get.
Next up, the Blue Gate Garden Inn trails just behind with a 9.3/10 rating. You’ll pay a bit more here—$190 per night—but it’s got that extra touch of comfort and style.
| Hotel | Booking Link | Rating | Luxury Level | Price per Night (2 Adults, USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Farmstead Inn and Conference Center | Book Now | 9.4 / 10 | ★★ | 162 |
| Blue Gate Garden Inn | Book Now | 9.3 / 10 | ★★ | 190 |
| Van Buren Hotel | Book Now | 8.9 / 10 | ★★ | 179 |
| Super 8 by Wyndham Shipshewana | Book Now | 8.3 / 10 | ★★ | 139 |
Note: All prices are excluding tax and are subject to change daily. Please refer to the booking page for the most up-to-date rates.
The Van Buren Hotel lands at an 8.9/10 rating with a $179 nightly rate. It’s got a bit of that old-school vibe if you’re into historic charm.
If you’re watching your wallet, Super 8 by Wyndham is the most affordable out of the Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels. At $139 per night, it still manages to deliver a solid experience.
All four of these spots keep things comfortable, each with their own twist. You’ll find two-star luxury across the board, so you won’t be sacrificing too much no matter your pick.
Honestly, I’d suggest booking directly through the links above if you want to catch the latest rates and make sure your dates are available. The Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels really do offer something for every type of traveler.
Ready to book your Shipshewana stay? Just click one of the booking links and lock in your spot at one of the Shipshewana Hotels TOP 4 Guest Favorite Hotels. There’s a reason these places keep topping the lists—why not see for yourself?
