Sturgeon Bay is the perfect gateway to Door County’s scenic attractions and waterfront adventures. With so many options, picking the right hotel can totally shape your experience at this Lake Michigan spot.
After digging around, I’ve zeroed in on the Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels that guests absolutely love. These places stand out for their unique charm, friendly service, and bang-for-your-buck value.
Each hotel brings something different to the table—maybe it’s historic vibes, maybe it’s killer waterfront views. Either way, you’ll find a spot that fits your style for your Sturgeon Bay stay.
1. Inn at Cedar Crossing: A Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotel
The Inn at Cedar Crossing is a boutique hotel right in downtown Sturgeon Bay. It’s got nine rooms, each with its own personality and style.
This historic spot dates back to the late 1800s, with original wood floors and doors that give it real character. But don’t worry—it still has modern touches like free WiFi, air conditioning, and flat-screen TVs in every room.
Guests always talk about the comfy beds and that cozy, homey feeling. It’s like staying at a friend’s place, if your friend happened to have a super cool old house.
You’ll find the inn on North 3rd Avenue, just a short stroll from local attractions. The Door County Historical Museum and Third Avenue Playhouse are practically around the corner.
Downstairs, Cedar Crossing Restaurant serves up meals all day. The bar next door is perfect for a nightcap without having to go out in the cold.
Each morning, guests get a complimentary continental breakfast from 7:00 AM to 10:30 AM. Think coffee, fresh baked goods, and all the basics to start your day right.
Parking is free on-site, but the lot can fill up quickly. Still, the location and historic charm make this one of the Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels for anyone who loves a bit of nostalgia.
Ready to check it out? See availability and grab your room at this top-rated Sturgeon Bay hotel.
2. Holiday Music Motel: Music Lover’s Pick Among Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels
The Holiday Music Motel calls itself the world’s only motel with live music and its own radio station. Built in 1952 and given a fresh update in 2009, it’s got a fun retro vibe mixed with modern comfort.
This place sits right downtown, steps from the waterfront. You can walk to shops, restaurants, and the Door County Maritime Museum without breaking a sweat.
All 18 rooms come with pillowtop beds, flat-screen TVs, and mini-fridges. Bathrooms have shower-tub combos and hair dryers, and WiFi is free throughout.
The music theme is more than just decor—songwriters actually use the rooms to create new tunes. The Tambourine Lounge next door hosts writers’ nights every Thursday, which is pretty cool if you ask me.
Other perks? Express check-in, free parking, and a common-area kitchenette that’s open 24/7. The staff here really go out of their way to make you feel welcome.
Travelers rave about the spotless rooms and quiet atmosphere. The retro style makes you feel like you’ve stepped back in time, but in a good way.
Want a stay that’s a little different? Book your room at Holiday Music Motel, one of the Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels, and see what everyone’s talking about.
3. Bridgeport Waterfront Resort: Family Favorite in the Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels
Bridgeport Waterfront Resort is all about location. It’s right on the water and just a quick four-minute walk from the Door County Maritime Museum.
The suites are roomy, with full kitchens and comfy living spaces. I noticed their 68 guest rooms all have microwaves, LCD TVs, and free WiFi, making it easy to settle in.
Guests can take a dip in the indoor or outdoor pools, or unwind in the hot tub. There are barbecue grills outside and plenty of free parking too.
Exploring is a breeze here. You can walk to restaurants, shops, and attractions in no time. Lots of guests mention the stunning waterfront views from their balconies—hard to beat that, honestly.
If you’re traveling with family or planning a longer visit, these suites are a great pick. Having a kitchen makes it simple to save on meals and still enjoy Door County’s best.
Some rooms overlook the water, while others face the parking lot. If you want the best views, ask for a waterfront room when you book—trust me, it’s worth it.
Bridgeport Waterfront Resort ranks high on review sites and regularly gets praised for its helpful staff, clean rooms, and unbeatable location. It’s no wonder it’s one of the Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels for families and groups.
Book your stay at Bridgeport Waterfront Resort to enjoy easy access to Sturgeon Bay’s top attractions and some seriously comfy accommodations.
Key Amenities and Services at the Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels
The Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels offer extras like indoor pools, hot tubs, and complimentary breakfast. Most are in downtown locations, so you can walk to restaurants and attractions or hop in your car for a quick drive across the Sturgeon Bay Bridge.
On-Site Dining Options at Sturgeon Bay Hotels
Most top-rated hotels in Sturgeon Bay serve complimentary continental breakfast with coffee bars. Expect pastries, cereals, fruit, and sometimes hot food too.
Some places, like the AmericInn by Wyndham, keep the coffee flowing all day. If you’re in a rush, a few hotels offer grab-and-go breakfast bags.
Bed and breakfast spots—think White Lace Inn—focus on local ingredients and regional specialties. It’s a nice touch if you love trying something new in the morning.
Full restaurants aren’t super common in Sturgeon Bay hotels, but you’ll find plenty of nearby places to eat. Staff are usually happy to recommend their favorites within walking distance.
Nearby Attractions
Staying at one of the Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels puts you close to everything. Most downtown hotels are within 500–900 feet of the Door County Historical Museum and Miller Art Museum.
Love the arts? Third Avenue PlayWorks and local galleries are just a short walk away. Novel Bay Booksellers is great for picking up local reads or regional guides.
The Door County Maritime Museum sits about 1,800 feet from most central hotels. It’s a must-visit if you’re curious about the area’s shipping past.
There are also parks like Martin Park and Graham Park nearby—good spots for a walk or just some downtime. Starboard Brewing Company is only 650 feet away for anyone who wants to sample local craft beer.
Transportation and Getting Around
Free self-parking is standard at the Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels. You’ll usually find on-site lots or easy street parking.
The city is compact, so walking to restaurants and attractions is easy. Most places you want to see are within a quarter-mile of your hotel.
If you’re heading out to other parts of Door County, highway access is straightforward. Hotels near the business district make it simple to reach Peninsula State Park and other hotspots.
Local taxis are available, but honestly, most visitors just walk. Many hotels hand out area maps with walking routes to their favorite spots.
Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels: Evaluation and Summary
Looking for the Top 3 Highly Rated Sturgeon Bay Hotels? I took a deep dive into guest reviews, amenities, and real value for money. These hotels each bring something different to the table—there’s honestly a lot to love here.
Holiday Music Motel grabs the spotlight with a stellar 9.4 out of 10 rating. It might only have two stars, but guests keep raving about the friendly service and its unbeatable location. At $160 per night, it’s hard not to call it excellent value for the area.
Inn at Cedar Crossing clocks in with a 9.3 rating. This one leans into 3-star luxury and historic charm, right in the heart of downtown. The $210 nightly rate reflects its premium feel and unique atmosphere.
Bridgeport Waterfront Resort sits right on the water, earning a solid 9.0 from guests. You get resort-style amenities and those dreamy lakefront views. At $208 per night, it’s a competitive pick among 3-star options, especially if you want to wake up by the lake.
| Hotel | Rating | Luxury Level | Price per Night (2 Adults) | Booking Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Inn at Cedar Crossing | 9.3 / 10 | ★★★ | USD 210 | Book Now |
| Holiday Music Motel | 9.4 / 10 | ★★ | USD 160 | Book Now |
| Bridgeport Waterfront Resort | 9.0 / 10 | ★★★ | USD 208 | Book Now |
Honestly, it’s smart to book directly through the links above for the latest rates and availability. Prices can change daily and don’t forget—taxes aren’t usually included in the first price you see. Double-check the final cost before you hit confirm.
